Dog Poo Bags Tested

We used to get biodegradable bags free from the council but they haven't had any for months now.  These are the best and worst of the cheap brands.  I didn't test any pack that cost more than £1.

Results:

Asda Smart Price Nappy Bags:

35p for 300  (0.001p each)

They are translucent orange and wafer thin so everybody can see (and smell) what you've got in your bag.  And if you swing it too much the chances are it will split open.

OK for if you're just picking up poo in your own garden but I wouldn't take them on a walk.

To be fair to Asda, they aren't poo bags, they're nappy bags and from vaguely remembered past experience they do the job they are designed for reasonably well.

Pet Pals Scented Pet Waste Bags: 

68p for 40 from Asda (0.017p each)

These are thick and work well.  Not very good value though, one pack doesn't last very long.

Petplace Scented Clean Up Bags:

£1 for 150 from Poundland (0.006p each)

Very thin, I found often the bag would rip down the length as I put my hand inside.  But OK for the money and best to use in the garden and not out on a walk (in case it splits and you have a sudden need for soap and hot water)

The Pet Shop Doggy Bags:
89p for 150 from B & M Bargains (0.005p each)
Really thick.  Scented.  Great value.  Highly recommended.

Bob Martin Biodegradable Poop Scoop Bags:
£1 for 60 from Tesco (0.016p each)
Thick and scented.  Not particularly good value but I would buy these just because they are biodegradable.

Conclusion:

Best:      The Pet Shop Doggy Bags from B & M Bargains
Worst:    Petplace Clean Up Bags from Poundland